President Donald Trump began his second term in January of 2025, and one of his main priorities was to crack down on immigration. In pursuit of this, he has taken multiple measures to increase deportation, the revocation of visas, and the detainment of noncitizens–regardless of status, criminal background, or legality. As a result, universities across the nation are experiencing unforeseen consequences regarding the free speech, safety, and security of their international students, as well as broader threats to their university culture. Using interviews and news monitoring, I explore how Trump’s immigration crackdowns impact higher education on a micro and macro scale, including individual emotions and behaviors, departmental changes, and the nature of resistance to his efforts. Focusing in on the University of Chicago, I explore how a university famously known for free expression is responding to these rapid changes, giving voice to international students and how they respond to this administration in real time. These findings shed light on the future of international talent in American higher education, and consequences of the Trump administration’s crackdowns, including brain drain, revenue decline, the loss of university culture, and broader threats to democracy at large.